A St. Louis-area teenage boy and a computer game have gone hands-off, thanks to a unique experiment conducted by a team of WUSTL neurosurgeons, neurologists and engineers.
The boy, a 14-year-old who suffers from epilepsy, is the first teenager to play a two-dimensional video game, “Space Invaders,” using only the signals from his brain to make movements.
Getting subjects to move objects using only their brains has implications toward some day building biomedical devices that can control artificial limbs, for instance, enabling the disabled to move a prosthetic arm or leg by thinking about it.
Many gamers think fondly of “Space Invaders,” one of the most popular breakthrough video games of the late ’70s. The player controls the motions of a movable laser cannon that moves back and forth across the bottom of the video screen.
Row upon row of video aliens march back and forth across the screen, slowly coming down from the top to the bottom of the screen. The objective is to prevent any one of the aliens from landing on the bottom of the screen, which ends the game. The player has an unlimited ammunition supply.
The aliens can shoot back at the player, who has to evade, moving left and right. There are lots of levels of play, reflecting the speed at which the aliens descend. The WUSTL subject mastered the first two levels of play using just his imagination.
The teenager had a grid atop his brain to record brain surface signals, a brain-machine interface technique that uses electrocorticographic (ECoG) activity — data taken invasively right from the brain surface.
It is an alternative to a frequently used technique to study humans called electroencephalographic activity — data taken non-invasively by electrodes outside the brain on the scalp. Engineers programmed the software to interface with the brain-machine interface system.
Eric C. Leuthardt, M.D., an assistant professor of neurological surgery at the School of Medicine, and Daniel Moran, Ph.D., assistant professor of biomedical engineering, performed their research on the boy who had the grids implanted so that neurologists and neurosurgeons can find the area in the brain serving as the focus for an epileptic seizure, with hopes of removing it to avoid future seizures.
To do this, the boy and his doctors, Matthew Smyth, M.D., assistant professor of neurosurgery and of pediatrics, and John Zempel, M.D., Ph.D., assistant professor of neurology and of pediatrics, had to wait for a seizure.
Usin’ the noggin
With approval of the patient and his parents and the WUSTL School of Medicine Institutional Review Board, Leuthardt and Moran connected the patient to a sophisticated computer running a special program known as BCI2000 (developed by their collaborator Gerwin Schalk at the Wadsworth Center, New York State Department of Health in Albany) which involves a video game that is linked to the ECoG grid.
They then asked the boy to do various motor and speech tasks, moving his hands various ways, talking and imagining. The team could see from the data which parts of the brain and what brain signals correlate to these movements.
The doctors asked the boy to play a simple, two-dimensional “Space Invaders” game by actually moving his tongue and hand. He then was asked to imagine the same movements — but not to actually perform them — with his hands or tongue. When he saw the cursor in the video game, he then controlled it with his brain.
“He cleared out the whole level one basically on brain control,” Leuthardt said. “He learned almost instantaneously. We then gave him a more challenging version in two dimensions and he mastered two levels there playing only with his imagination.”
In 2004, Leuthardt and Moran led a team which was the first to perform this research on four adult patients. The researchers were anxious to get data from a teenager to see if there are any differences between how teens and adults operate.
“It’s exciting to be able to look at age differences and see what that tells us about the brain,” said Moran, who added that the team plans to test more pediatric subjects. “No one has ever seen if brain signals from children are different.
“We’ll try to determine if teenagers have different frequency distributions when their cortex becomes active. We might question if the frequency alterations are different — will that make a difference in performance?”
Leuthardt said it is too early to make comparisons between adults and teenagers because they have only one set of teenage data.
“But we observed much quicker reaction times in the boy and he had a higher level of detail of control — for instance, he wasn’t moving just left and right, but just a little bit left, a little bit right,” he said.
Graduate students in the School of Engineering and Applied Science played major roles in the accomplishment. Nick Anderson, a doctoral student in biomedical engineering, came up with the idea of using the “Space Invaders” game to both help the patients pass the time away and garner some very useful, pioneering data. Computer science and engineering master’s degree candidate Tim Blakely pulled several all-nighters to program the game into the ECoG system.
“Doing this is a win-win situation, both for science and the child,” Leuthardt said. “We devised this to be enjoyable and entertaining while we get groundbreaking information on the brain.”
The clinical team also played a significant role in the planning and orchestration of this research. It was of critical importance that these experiments be safe and not interfere with clinical care.
The clinical pediatric portion of the team was led by Smyth and Zempel.
“This really was a symphony of expertise ranging from neurosurgery, neurology, neuroscience, engineering and computer science, which was years in the making. The end result is something we can really be proud of,” Leuthardt said.