What’s up with Madagascar?

Why are there volcanoes on an island that isn’t near any tectonic boundaries?

Curious onlookers surround Ghassan Aleqabi (gray suit coat), seismic installation specialist at Washington University in St. Louis, and Madagascaran graduate student Fenitra Andriampenomanana (white shirt to Ghassan's left) as they install a seismic station at Mandritsara in Northern Madagascar. (Photo: Martin Pratt)

Madagascar, the big island off the east coast of Africa with the lemurs and baobabs, is thought to be sitting in the middle of an old tectonic plate, and so, by the rules of plate tectonics, should be tectonically quiet: few earthquakes and no volcanoes.

But it’s not. The island has been away from tectonic action for the past 80 million years, said Martin Pratt, research scientist in earth and planetary sciences at Washington University in St. Louis, yet it experiences about 500 earthquakes per year.

Betahezana, Ngilofotsy, Andranonatoa volcanic domes in teh Ankaratra volcanic field on Madagascar.
Field of volcanoes on the island of Madagascar puzzles geologists. What is the source of the heat that melts the rock? (Photo: Rando Trek VTT)

The island also has volcanoes that have been active within the recent geologic past. “Having active volcanoes in Madagascar is like having erupting volcanoes in St. Louis,” said Michael Wysession, professor of earth and planetary sciences. “You have to ask yourself, ‘What are they doing there?’”

Since this part of the world is geologically complex, there are lots of interesting possible explanations for the volcanoes. To figure it out, the geologists needed to be able to examine not just the island’s accessible surface, but also what lies beneath the rigid crust and upper mantle.

To image Earth’s interior, geologists use a technique called seismic tomography that is similar to the medical CT scan, probing the earth’s strictire with seismic waves from distant earthquakes and ambient noise. But remote and politically unstable Madagascar was largely unexplored by seismic methods until recently.

Starting in 2010, however, three groups, including one led by Washington University seismologists Wysession and Doug Wiens, began to deploy seismic arrays on Madagascar, on nearby islands in the Mozambique channel (between the island and Africa), and on the ocean floor east of Madagascar.

In an article published online Nov. 22 in Earth and Planetary Science Letters, the Washington University scientists report that they found three areas of hot rock within the mantle beneath three separate volcanic provinces on the island.


Pictured above is the crack Washington University installation crew: Michael Wysession (left), Patrick Shore (blue shirt), Ghassan Aleqabi (white cap) and AfricaArray graduate students Fenitra Andriampenomanana (crouched, white shirt) and Tsiriandrimanana Rakotondraibe (gray shirt, blue and white cap) at work. Madagascar as been called the Great Red Island because of the color of its soil.

“Two Madagascan students, Fenitra and Tsitsi, are participating in a fabulous program called AfricaArray, started by our co-author Andy Nyblade of Penn State University,” Wysession said.

They are working with students from across Africa toward doctoral degrees from the University of Witswatersrand in South Africa, but they also each have separate projects funded by other sources. “Fenitra and Tsitsi are supported from our NSF grants, collaborated with us on all stages of the project, and are now publishing papers on other aspects of the island’s tectonics,” Wysession said.

They also see signs that the bottom of the lithosphere beneath the central volcanic province has peeled off. As the cold rock sank into the mantle, hotter rock flowed around it to the center and the south of the island. The crust, unburdened, bobbed higher. The northern volcanic province, meanwhile, probably taps a different heat source.

A busted-up chunk of an ancient continent

Madagascar, originally part of the ancient continent Gondwana, was formed in two steps. The island, together with India, pulled away from Africa 150 million years ago, stretching and thinning the crust on the island’s west coast before it finally snapped off. The thinned crust on the west coast sagged and the dips filled with sediments, forming deep basins of sedimentary rocks.

Then, about 90 million years ago, when the mini-continent migrated over the Marion hotspot (a mantle plume that now lies beneath the Antarctic plate to the south), brief but voluminous eruptions covered the island in lava. The blast of heat is thought to have cracked the overriding continent into two parts, Madagascar and India, which scraped past the east coast of Madagascar on its way north toward Asia, leaving a very straight coastline there.

But the volcanism in the central, northern, and southern provinces are much younger than the basaltic remains of the 90-million-year-old eruption still found around the perimeter of Madagascar. So the question was: Where did they come from?

What the images show

Lead-author Pratt used three complementary methods to analyze surface waves (seismic waves trapped near Earth’s surface), which are created by distant earthquakes and from sources of seismic noise, such as ocean storms.

“His approach is clever and creative,” Wysession said. “He’s taken three really different data sets, some good at high frequencies that give you better resolution at shallow depths, and some better at low frequencies that give you better resolution at greater depths, and he’s put them all together. It’s a bit like combining an X-ray, an MRI and a CT scan to get a clearer image.”

Seismic images show areas of hotter rock underlying areas of recent (Cenozoic) volcanism on the island. Image: Martin Pratt
Seismic images showed areas of hotter rock underlying elevated areas of recent volcanism (NMAP and CMAP on the seismic image; red outlines on the inset map). (Image: Martin Pratt)



The images show three low-velocity seismic anomalies corresponding to the upwelling of hotter mantle rock along the island’s backbone.

“We knew about the named volcanic provinces in the center and north,” Wysession said. “But we didn’t know about the one in the southwest. When we saw the third blob in the images, we checked the literature and discovered that, sure enough, there was volcanic activity there as recently as 9 million years ago.”

The cause of the three hot regions in the mantle is a mystery, however. Though there is some indication from the tomographic images that the regions might be connected, particularly the southern two, further modeling of deeper structure will be needed to confirm.

One origin of the hot regions previously has been proposed to be hot rock rising through the mantle as the Comores hot spot, which has created a set of volcanic islands just west of the north end of the island.

Then a wheel fell off

Asked if he had any adventures installing seismometers in Madagascar, Martin Pratt admits he had at least one uncomfortable moment.

He, Ghassan Aleqabi and Madagascaran graduate student Tsiriandrimanana Rakotondraibe were installing broadband seismometers near the capital city of Antanarivo, including one at an existing station.

“It turns out this station was at the top of a honking big extinct volcano,” he said, “and the road up to it was rubbish. It took us about two hours to drive up there. When we got within about two kilometers of the summit — where we were going to put the station — the right rear wheel of the truck fell off.”

They hiked all the equipment the remaining two kilometers to the site, and then settled in to wait for their driver, who had gone down to a tiny village to try to get a lift to the nearest big town.

“Early the next morning we were still there,” he said. “Just us and one other guy. It was pitch black and it had started to blow a bit of wind and you could see in the distance all these wildfires from the slash-and-burn agriculture. one of those wildfires was getting to be very close.

“It occurred to us that maybe nobody was coming back,” Pratt said.

The authors have a different idea, however, and it comes from the way that the central and southwestern provinces appear to be connected at depth.

“If you look at the images that Martin has made,” Wysession said, “you can see a horseshoe shape where the central hot mantle anomaly swings west and then comes back east again, connecting the central and southern provinces.

The deflecting obstacle seems to be a slab of colder rock. “We think the lithosphere (the crust and rigid upper mantle) has delaminated, and the bottom of it fell off,” Wysession said. “As the cold, dense slab began to sink, hotter rock flowed up and in to replace it, buoying the central province and, as it tilted, blocking flow to the south.”

But what caused the bottom of the lithosphere to peel off? “We think it may have been the Marion hotspot,” Wysession said. “The underside of the plate was heated by this huge blow torch 95 million years ago, weakening the rock enough that it was able to peel off. So we’re still seeing collateral damage from this ancient event.”

This idea also has the advantage of explaining the unusually high elevations of the northern half of the island. Once the heavy bottom of the plate fell off, it stopped pulling down the crust, which rebounded upward as much as a kilometer as hot rock from below took the place of the delaminated slab.

Something similar happened underneath the Great Basin of the western United States, he said, where the bottom of the lithosphere also split off, forming a large blob of cold material sinking down through the mantle below the surface of central Nevada. There, the blow torch that delaminated the plate was an ocean spreading center that was overridden by the North American plate, Wysession said.

This worked was funded by NSF award EAR-0838426.
Leave a Comment

Comments and respectful dialogue are encouraged, but content will be moderated. Please, no personal attacks, obscenity or profanity, selling of commercial products, or endorsements of political candidates or positions. We reserve the right to remove any inappropriate comments. We also cannot address individual medical concerns or provide medical advice in this forum.